Real life. Real strategy. Turned all the way up.
Note from Michaela
Would you please take 2 minutes to tell us what you want from LOUDER in 2027? Click here for the survey
The holiday debate at my house has officially started: when (and if) the tree goes up. Meanwhile, the outdoor lights are already on. From the street, it looks like we have it all together. Inside, the tree is still a hypothetical.
There's still so much to be thankful for. This time of year has a way of turning my perspective in that direction.
It's also a reminder that plenty of things look finished from the outside long before the real work is done. Your 2027 plan is about to be one of them. Somewhere between now and Thanksgiving, it gets its final sign-off. The board deck looks good. The budget closes. Everyone exhales.
Then the plan leaves the boardroom and gets delivered in one-on-ones, by your managers, over the next ten weeks. My last two issues covered the comp budget and the real cost of "no." This one is about the people who have to say it.
TL;DR
Between now and the end of January, your managers will deliver performance reviews, pay decisions, and 2027 goals, often in the same conversation. Before Thanksgiving, give them the message, the numbers they can share, and the words to use when the answer is no.
Execution rarely breaks at the top. It breaks in the middle, one conversation at a time.
YOUR 2027 PLAN IS APPROVED. CAN YOUR MANAGERS DELIVER IT?
Look at what lands on a first-line manager's desk over the next ten weeks: year-end reviews, merit and bonus conversations, 2027 goals, and in a lot of PE-backed companies, an integration or reorg update on top of it. All of it wrapped around the holidays and PTO.
Most of those managers were promoted because they were great at the work. When Gallup asked U.S. managers why they believed they got the job, they commonly pointed to success in a previous non-managerial role or their tenure. Being great at the job is not the same as being ready to explain a 3% merit increase to your best performer.
That gap matters more than most leadership teams account for. Gallup estimates that managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement scores across business units. In plain terms: when two teams in the same company feel completely different, the manager is usually the reason. Same plan. Same budget. Different manager. Different Q1.
Execution rarely breaks at the top. It breaks in the middle, one conversation at a time.
Before the year-end conversations start, give your managers three things:
The message. What does 2027 ask of their team, in plain language? If a manager can't explain the plan in two sentences, their team won't be able to either.
The numbers, and the rules. Merit ranges, bonus timing, what's final and what isn't. Calibrate ratings before anyone sits down, so the right raise goes to the right people and nobody rates generously to dodge a hard conversation. A manager guessing is worse than a manager saying, "That isn't decided yet. You'll have an answer by January 15."
The script for no. Not every request gets a yes. Decide what a manager can honestly offer instead (scope, development, a date to revisit) and who they call when a conversation goes sideways. The first call should not be the CEO.
None of this requires a leadership academy or a 40-slide training deck. It requires one prepared hour before the conversations start, instead of three cleanup hours after.
This month's move: Before Thanksgiving, get your managers in a room for 60 minutes. Walk them through the 2027 plan, what's decided on pay, and how to handle a no. Then ask each one: Which conversation on your team are you most worried about? You'll learn more about your Q1 risk in that hour than in any spreadsheet.
Your plan gets approved in the boardroom. It gets delivered in a one-on-one.
On My Radar
📖 Reading: Dungeon Crawler Carl — Don't ask, not my usual read. Oddly amusing. It happened by accident on a “just killing time” visit to the bookstore. Might even read the next one…
🎧 Listening: In the market for a new podcast. Hit reply and send me your favorite.
📺 Watching: Football. College (Fork ‘em, Devils!) and NFL seems to own the TV these days. And the family fantasy league is epic, and Thanksgiving bragging rights are on the line.
👍🏻 Saying Yes to: Outdoor lights already on (tree still TBD), and prepping managers before the year-end conversations, not after.

